An Energy Year in Review: Annus Horribilis or Annus Mirabilis?

Sponsored by

by Tanya Bodell, Energyzt

The end of the year has arrived, along with a compelling inclination to recount this year’s highlights. In 2012, the power sector experienced several notable events that serve as harbingers for the new year.

Gas Prices Hit New Lows

The industry watched in awe last winter and spring as Henry Hub gas prices plummeted to below $2 per million British thermal units. Initially unclear about whether the decline was temporary, the industry seems to have accepted that prices not seen since the 1990s might be here to stay until drilling cuts back and new demand enters. Expect continuation of announced rig reductions, increasing investment by petrochemical manufacturers, and stubbornly low gas prices.

Natural Gas, Coal-fired Generators Reach Parity

In April, natural gas and coal-fired power plants produced nearly the same amount of energy. This event represents a larger trend of coal displacement by natural gas resulting from higher coal prices because of exports and declining natural gas prices from new shale supply. For the first time, coal and natural gas generation is at parity in price and production—a temporary phenomenon until gas, coal and power markets settle into a new equilibrium. Expect continued competition at the margin between natural gas and coal-fired plants until coal plant retirements come to fruition.

Large Utility Mergers

Several utility megamergers occurred this past year. In the spring, Northeast Utilities completed its $4.17 billion takeover of NSTAR. Maryland regulators approved Exelon Corp.’s proposed $7.9 billion takeover of Constellation Energy Group. During the summer, Duke Energy Corp. and Progress Energy completed their $32 billion merger. In the fall, NRG Energy Inc. and Gen-On Energy Inc. jointly won notice from the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission granting early termination of the waiting period under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976 for their $18 billion merger. Mergers of this magnitude are common in a maturing industry where revenue growth is challenged and the quest for high profit margins must resort to transactions. Expect to see continued acquisitions and large-scale mergers as the industry struggles with flat demand growth.

Demand-side Market Manipulation

In July, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued four orders directed toward participants in New England’s Day-Ahead Load Response Program. FERC requested a showing of why those participants should not be found to have manipulated the load response market and required to disgorge payments totaling $26.5 million. There are three precedent-setting aspects of these orders: FERC’s anti-market manipulation investigation and enforcement powers are being applied to demand response markets; the orders named two market participants, their consultant and his consulting firm, targeting those who perpetrated the action as well as those who advised them to do so; and substantial penalties are being assessed. Market participants and advisors on the demand side of energy markets beware.

A Whirlwind of Renewable Energy Activity

With federal production tax credit (PTC) and investment grants’ expiring at the end of last year, wind developers have spent most of this year frantically working to complete projects to meet the in-service date deadline of Dec. 31. Biomass and geothermal projects, which have in-service date deadlines, will see similarly frantic activity next year. In the meantime, photovoltaic solar is the new focus, with a continued investment tax credit through 2016, multiple states’ offering generous incentives, and significant cost reductions because of technological and manufacturing improvements. Unless the PTC is renewed, expect a continued renewable energy shift away from wind turbines.

No New Energy Act … Yet

The most recent Energy Policy Act was passed by Congress and signed into law by President George W. Bush on Aug. 8, 2005. Energy policy tends to be renewed approximately every five years, making the next overdue. With the courts’ overturning the EPA’s proposed cross-state air pollution regulations in August and a growing challenge to the administration’s back-door strategy of implementing carbon policy through regulatory decrees, expect the Obama administration to turn to energy matters.

For certain energy market participants, these events were awful; for others, they were wonderful. Whichever they were for you, best wishes for a prosperous new year!


Tanya Bodell is executive director of Energyzt, a collaboration of energy experts intent on understanding the impacts of energy integration. Reach her at 617-416-0651 or

“History teaches everything including the future.” – Lamartine

More Electric Light & Power Current Issue Articles
More Electric Light & Power Archives Issue Articles

Sponsored by


Polish government to focus on coal power plants over nuclear


This represents somewhat of a U-turn from Poland's earlier plans

FERC accepts PG&E transmission rate hike, sets hearing


PG&E made the filing to recover costs tied to transmission expansion and replacement projects  

Nevada regulators agree on One Nevada Transmission Line

10/05/2015 The transaction is tied to the California ISO’s selection of a transmission developer to build a new 500-kV line  

Xcel mulls retiring coal units, replacing with gas power plants

10/05/2015 The new, bigger and cleaner-emitting Sherco Unit 3, also fired with coal, is not part of this shutdown discussion. 

Isolux Corsan energizes substation for EHV transmission project in India

10/05/2015 The network will enable evacuating the energy from new power plants and will transport it through the state   &n...

Gemma Power Systems wins OK to build 475 MW gas plant in Ohio


The Middletown Energy Center project is scheduled to be completed in the second quarter of 2018    

Deal on Pepco-Exelon merger reportedly pitched with D.C. mayor


The office of Mayor Muriel Bowser presented this reported deal to interested groups 


How certified T&D components help to improve power network performance

Electricity is the life blood of modern society. Any interruption to its supply can have a huge i...

Moisture in Transformer Oil Behavior – a Deeper Look into a Complex Phenomenon

As our understanding of how moisture movement in transformers improves, so does the evolution of ...

Connecting the Physical and Digital Domains: Intelligent Integration for a Smart City

Free Webcast Series from Leidos | Part 2 of 2 - Connecting the Physical and Digital Domains: Inte...

Leveraging Intelligent Infrastructure to Achieve Your Smart City Vision

Free Webcast Series from Leidos | Part 1 of 2 - Leveraging Intelligent Infrastructure to Achieve ...

Successfully Integrating Solar: A Proactive Approach

•      What does the increasing solar penetration mean to you as a utili...




Aurora™ is a proprietary blend of alumino-silicate based minerals engineered to treat a boiler's fireside system against slagging, fouling and corr...

Swage Bus Accessories

By using a compression technology process called "swaging," aluminum bus accessories can be installed without a welder. Products include bus couple...

Decontamination & Decommissioning

Decommissioning strategy development, cost estimates, plant modifications; system and building decontamination; RV segmentation; large component re...

Nuclear Horizontal Modular Storage (NUHOMS®)

AREVA TN’s NRC-licensed NUHOMS® system ensures the highest safety and lowest dose performance. With no tipping, tripping and sliding, you have the...


Meyer - Engineered Poles

As your comprehensive resource for any configuration of tubular steel structure, Meyer works closely with you to develop e...

LD Poles

The standard designs and high-strength material used in the fabrication of our Light Duty steel poles insures confidence t...

Standard H-Frames

Meyer Steel Structures has compiled a database of existing steel H-frame designs that could be used to quickly meet your n...

Systems & Utility Technology Selection

BRIDGE’s utility business and functional system experts with specific experience in today’s ‘best of breed’ business syste...


View more Job Listings >>

POWERGRID International

March 2015
Volume 20, Issue 3


January 2015
Volume 93, Issue 1