Primer on supercritical steam

Sponsored by

Dr. Martin Alf and John Kern
Siemens Power Generation

Thermodynamics govern the ultimate performance of Rankine cycles whether they are used in a coal fired steam power plant or the bottoming cycle of a combined cycle plant. In order to increase the efficiency of those cycles, higher pressure and temperature steam conditions are desired. As a result, many coal fired steam plants being built and planned around the world today utilize "supercritical" steam conditions to achieve higher efficiency. To learn about this subject, EL&P spoke to Dr. Martin Alf and John Kern with Siemens Power Generation.

What is supercritical steam?

When the pressure in a boiler exceeds the "critical" pressure of 3208 psi, water and steam have the same density and no longer exist as separate phase states. Steam conditions above the critical pressure are referred to as "supercritical." Because the water and steam don't have to be separated in a boiler drum, once-through boilers of a Benson or Sulzer design are typically used to generate supercritical steam. These once-through boilers also make it easier to generate steam at higher temperatures, further improving plant efficiency.

What are the benefits when compared to subcritical units?

Typical steam parameters used in sub-critical reheat steam plants are 2400 psi/1000°F/1000°F while modern supercritical units are operating at steam conditions above 3900 psi/1075°F/1110°F. These more advanced steam conditions result in a net plant efficiency of up to 45 percent, which is a 3.5 percent improvement over a subcritical unit. Higher steam conditions yield higher efficiencies, which means that less coal is used to generate the same amount of electricity, compared to a subcritical unit.

Higher plant efficiency also reduces the production of all pollutants by up to 8 percent. This reduction translates into lower emissions of CO2 and mercury, which are difficult to control with current technologies.

How do supercritical steam conditions affect plant design and cost?

Once-through boilers used in supercritical plants have a number of differences from the drum-type boiler typically used in subcritical plants. In a once-through design, water is completely evaporated in a single pass through the boiler rather than re-circulating through the drum. Current designs for once-through boilers use a spiral wound furnace or incorporate vertical tubing with rifled inner surfaces to assure even heat distribution across the tubes. Since once-through systems don't have a drum to concentrate and remove impurities, they usually require a condensate polisher and use oxygenated water chemistry to maintain steam purity. Recent advances in high temperature materials (such as T-91), provide high temperature strength and improved corrosion resistance, permitting reliable operation in advanced steam cycles, thus improving thermal efficiency.

The design of the high-pressure (HP) element on the steam turbine takes into consideration the higher steam forces and higher pressure drop between HP inlet and exhaust. To accommodate this higher pressure, the number of stages in the turbine is increased and the cylinder wall is thickened. Rotor and cylinder components are upgraded to enhanced 10 - 12 percent chrome steels to withstand higher temperatures and pressures. Full-arc admission and simplified inlet features are used to take advantage of the flexibility and efficiency benefits provided by the sliding pressure capability of once-through boilers and to reduce solid particle erosion in the turbine.

While system processes and plant arrangements for balance of plant are basically the same, the higher supercritical pressures use smaller diameter pipes with thicker pipe walls. Additional systems such as the condensate polisher are required, but all of the coal handling and emissions control equipment can be sized smaller due to increased plant efficiency.

Because total plant costs vary considerably depending on project scope and specifications, it is difficult to make a direct comparison between sub- and supercritical capital costs. Most sources indicate that for a comparably sized plant, the EPC cost for a supercritical unit will be 2 - 5 percent higher.

How does the operation of a supercritical plant differ from a subcritical plant?

Operational differences stem mainly from the dissimilarity between a once-through boiler and a drum-type boiler. The drum boiler holds a greater stored water/steam volume, which allows larger load step-changes that can be helpful for operation on weak transmission grids. For ramping changes over large load ranges, as required for cycling operation, the once-through boiler is significantly faster due to its thinner walled components and smaller storage capacity. These design characteristics also allow supercritical plants to have a shorter start-up time. When combined with the sliding pressure capability of modern steam turbines, supercritical plants offer a higher degree of operational flexibility and reduced load efficiency than subcritical units equipped with a drum type boiler.

Operation and maintenance costs are about the same for the two designs. Supercritical units will have added costs for the condensate polisher and more sophisticated maintenance requirements, but will have lower costs for consumables such as limestone, ammonia and fuel due to higher efficiency levels.

How have recent supercritical plants performed?

Performance problems that plagued the second-generation supercritical plants that went into operation in the 1960s and 1970s have been largely resolved. These issues have not been seen on the third generation plants that have gone into service over the past 15 years. Evaluations of the availability and reliability of comparably sized sub- and supercritical power plants over the past 10 years using databases from NERC and the European agencies show no significant differences in performance between the two plant types.

What "factors" might impact the choice?

The choice between sub- and supercritical technology needs to be made early in the plant design phase and can be influenced by a number of site and operational considerations. The lower operating costs that directly result from higher efficiency supercritical steam cycles can be a strong influence if delivered fuel prices are above average or if the plant has to compete on "spark-spread" with other coal plants. In both cases, slightly higher supercritical capital costs will be justified by the more favorable operating costs.

In addition, if the plant has to compete in a market that might require cycling or reduced load operation, units with once-through boilers have a clear advantage.

The most important factor might be the potential for easier environmental permitting with a supercritical unit. Higher efficiency translates into reduced environmental impact. Less coal and water are used, smaller volumes of fly ash and scrubber waste is produced, and uncontrolled emissions of CO2 and mercury will be lowered. Exactly how environmental agencies will view this benefit is uncertain, but it is expected to become an increasingly important part of an effective permitting strategy.

Alf is the project manager for steam power plants in Erlangen, Germany. Kern is the director of steam turbine and steam plant marketing in Orlando, Florida. Siemens Power Generation's supercritical technology has achieved record efficiency levels of over 48 percent.

Sponsored by

CURRENT ARTICLES

Black & Veatch wins contract for Ohio combined cycle gas plant

11/21/2014

The power plant is expected to begin commercial operations by July 2017 

Energy efficient building revenue in Europe to reach $109 billion by 2023

11/21/2014 Stringent regulations that apply across the European Union have contributed to the development of a growing market for ene...

FERC approves Pepco, Exelon merger

11/21/2014 The combination of the companies will bring together Exelon’s three electric and gas utilities — BGE, ComEd and PECO — and...

Mexico spends $11 billion on renewable energy since 2003

11/20/2014 Mexico's renewable energy sector received $11 billion in direct foreign investment during the 2003-13 decade, with wind po...

NRC chair: Work needed to finish Fukushima changes

11/20/2014 Allison Macfarlane said the agency must follow through on changes required after the March 2011 crisis at the Fukushima Da...

Panda Power Funds dedicates 758 MW Sherman Power Plant

11/20/2014

The Panda Sherman facility has the capacity to continuously supply the power needs of up to 758,000 homes

Electric Light & Power Executive Conference sets utility speakers record

11/20/2014

Recently added speakers include a utility CEO, Walmart exec and British knight

INDUSTRY STOCKS

ON DEMAND WEBCASTS

Benefits of a Managed Service System

Attend this webinar, sponsored by Itron, to understand how utilizing managed services can optimiz...

Architecting Communication Networks for Smart Grids

This webinar will provide the essentials of communication networking to meet the challenges of th...

The Power of Behavioral Design: Lessons for Energy Efficiency Providers

Behavioral design principles are key differentiators when it comes to influencing consumer behavi...

3D BIM for Substations—Driving Efficiency from Design Through Operation and Maintenance

In this webinar, PESTECH will describe their transition to intelligent substation design and its ...

High Availability Networks. Application of IEC6439-3 Protocols for IEC61850 Process Bus implementation

Networks can now be built for the first time with genuinely uninterrupted data communication betw...

EL&P BUYER'S GUIDE PRODUCTS

MITEM Corp

Provides CRM solutions for regulated U.S. public utilities. The product, MitemView integrates differently designed systems to share critical data a...

Resources on Demand

Manages resource requests, tracks personnel movements, and supports lodging/logistics during a power restoration event.

Smart Grids

Quanta is contributing to its customers' smart grid initiatives by installing technology on power networks to provide energy management solutions f...

Horizontal Directional Drilling

With 28 small, mid-sized and large drilling rigs, Quanta Pipeline Services is one of the largest horizontal directional contractors in the world fo...

POWERGRID PRODUCT LISTINGS

EtherMate® Industrial Ethernet - IO Modules

LioN-M ProfiNet device with 16 digital I/O channels, channels can be used universally as inputs or outputs, M12 socket, ro...

Low-Smoke Zero Halogen Premise Distribution Cable

AFL’s Low-Smoke Zero Halogen (LSZH) distribution cable offers all of the benefits of a traditional 900 µm based optical ca...

OFL280 FlexTester - Handheld OTDR

AFL's OFL280 FlexTester offers an unmatched combination of fiber test functions, ease-of-use, portability, and value.

TRM® 2.0 - Test Results Manager PC Analysis and Reporting

Test Results Manager 2.0 (TRM® 2.0) is an all-in-one analysis, viewer and reporting tool designed for use with NOYES fiber...

FEATURED ENERGY JOBS

View more Job Listings >>

POWERGRID International

October 2014
Volume 19, Issue 10
1410pg_C1digital

ELECTRIC LIGHT & POWER

October 2014
Volume 92, Issue 5
1409ELP-cover_digital