Prepaid Metering Can Bring Strays Back To Your Fold

Sponsored by

By Kathleen Davis, Associate Editor

Let's get one thing straight right off the bat: Prepaid billing—also known as prepaid metering—is not exploding. It's not off the charts. It's not through the roof.

Click here to enlarge image

Prepaid billing is, however, establishing a small enclave of happy customers, and that's a start for utilities using the systems, like Salt River Project. They are seeing certain demographics—who are traditionally unhappy with utilities in general—sing Salt River's praises, and the praises of prepaid billing as a whole.

"Customers love the program," said John Soethe, manager of revenue cycle services with Salt River Project. "A lot of times customers are on prepay because they have had problems managing their past bills; so, having them be happy with the program and keeping up with their usage is great for us."

The Leading Example

Salt River Project's (SRP) prepaid metering project, known as M-Power, currently has 31,000 enrolled customers and uses Motorola technology with a smart meter on the side of the home. There is also an in-home display unit, the UDT (user display terminal). The Motorola technology utilizes powerline carrier technology to allow the UDT to communicate with the meter, a system that Soethe labels "top of the line."

The customer is given a smart card when they enroll in the program, and they use the card to make "purchases" at any one of Salt River's pay centers. There are approximately 43 of those pay centers located around the Phoenix metropolitan area where customers can purchase power in any amount from $1 to $500.

The credit is moved onto the card to be used in the UDT and loaded onto the meter. Credit can be loaded even if there is a surplus already attached to the meter.

"It's just like putting gas in your car," Soethe said. "When your gas gauge gets low, you stop and fill your tank back up."

SRP's program does contain a service charge (approximately $5 a month) to help the utility recover a bit of the program's higher equipment costs, but Soethe stated that the reduction of consumption by consumers on the program more than offsets the costs. The UDT gives customers a very tangible look at how much electricity they are using on a daily basis. They can move around by day, week, or month in that data, or even switch to real-time consumption, which can give them a better understanding of how much it costs to run various home appliances.

"I think this is one of the big benefits of the program for the customers," Soethe said. "It allows them to take control of their electric usage, which, before, had been pretty much a mystery to them."

He added, "Once customers understand how they are using electricity, they become better consumers. They make better choices, and their overall consumption actually drops—on average—about 10 percent."

The only glitch in SRP's prepaid future at this point is that "top of the line" technology. Motorola is pulling out of the prepaid metering business.

"They made a business decision to exit, but SRP is committed to prepay," Soethe stated. "We are actively evaluating all options at this time, but we are in the early stages of that process."

Of History and Technology

Motorola's exit made quite a ripple on the horizon of prepay. They were the leading vendor in the arena, and some see the company's exit as a sign of decline in this AMR niche. And, it is true that prepaid billing/metering is not a booming growth industry—not according to the latest Chartwell report on the subject.

Chartwell's "Prepaid Metering Report 2003" states that technology costs and regulatory red tape continue to prevent many U.S. utilities from implementing prepay programs.

"What has been the largest stumbling block on the regulatory side is how public utility commissions view prepaid billing and metering," said Garrett Johnston, research analyst and managing editor with Chartwell. "Accurate or not, PUCs and public officials still believe that prepaid programs can too easily cut off lower income or struggling customers. And they aren't happy about that.

"Now there has been more education in that arena, but, unfortunately, that stigma still exists."

And, of course, that cost of $350 to $400 per "point of contact" (usually one residential household) is also a large factor in keeping prepaid quiet.

According to Chartwell's report, similar to residential time-of-use rates, prepaid metering is something many utility officials think about, but few utilities are actually offering. Only 2 percent of utilities in their survey of 115 have prepaid programs, although 25 percent of utilities are considering them. (See figure.)

Click here to enlarge image

Chartwell's report pointed to this lack of penetration as a possible cause for Motorola's exit.

"The market is not a high-growth market," Johnston stated. "It's a hard market to make a lot of profit in, and you're going to have to bide your time.

"If the market ever hits big, however, Motorola might return," he added. "You never know."

But there are still prepaid metering vendors with more than a just toe in the pool. One, CIC Global, has even worked with Salt River Project in the past. The company has been in the prepaid business in the U.S., New Zealand and Australia since 1986, and they have no plans on pulling out—even if the current niche is a small one.

"Customers are asking for these systems," stated Jon Thomas, president of CIC Global. "People brag about it. And, enough word of mouth, enough phone calls to utilities asking about the service, and the market moves forward significantly.

"It can be popular when it's actually provided, and that's the bottom line," Thomas added.

Thomas admitted that the cost of prepaid metering is a significant capital investment for utilities (due to extra equipment, mostly) but he pointed out a number of underlying factors not covered in general surveys—among those, that customers might be willing to pay a bit more to prepay, the way some are willing to pay more for green power. This, along with the fact that consumers often reduce energy consumption and that these meters are equipped with smart technology that may enable more enhancements in the future (and quicker and easier enhancements), could, in the end, make prepaid metering cost-effective down the line, if utilities are willing to look that way. And, of course, at the basic level, prepaid billing helps utilities serve an oft-problematic customer base.

Thomas believes that running those numbers alone could even out the 3-to-1 cost of prepaid meters.

"Prepayment metering—whether a customer favorite or not—is a revenue protection system for the utility," Thomas said. "So, utilities can look at this very narrowly as well: That this system is a way for us to reduce our bad debt and problems associated with people who aren't paying bills, disconnects, reconnects. There is a cost savings right there."

"In the end, the benefits of prepay are still unfolding," SRP's Soethe said. "They will be fully realized in the years to come."

Sponsored by

CURRENT ARTICLES

RWE connects solar farm to U.K. power grid

10/30/2014

The solar park has been constructed and commissioned by global downstream company Conergy 

Power4Georgians gets 18-month extension on coal plant air permit

10/29/2014 The extension will give Power4Georgians time to determine if or how Plant Washington will be affected by that CO2 rule

SunEdison finances 69.5 MW solar power plant in Chile

10/29/2014 Solar power technology manufacturer SunEdison Inc. announced the closing of a $130 million non-recourse debt financing arr...

Texas regulators to approve 138-kV transmission line

10/29/2014

The length of the 16 route alternatives that GVEC filed in the application ranged from about nine miles to 12 miles

Siemens, Mortenson win HVDC transmission contract in Canada

10/29/2014 In a consortium with Mortenson Construction, Siemens will be supplying both converter stations for the Bipole III HVDC pro...

FirstEnergy returns Perry to service after unplanned outage

10/29/2014

The plant experienced an unexpected shut down at 2:18 a.m. on Monday, Oct. 20, a FirstEnergy spokesperson said  

Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems to build 25 MW geothermal plant in Mexico

10/29/2014 To date, MHPS has received 12 other orders from Mexico’s Comisión Federal de Electricidad for geothermal power plants from...

ON DEMAND WEBCASTS

Architecting Communication Networks for Smart Grids

This webinar will provide the essentials of communication networking to meet the challenges of th...

The Power of Behavioral Design: Lessons for Energy Efficiency Providers

Behavioral design principles are key differentiators when it comes to influencing consumer behavi...

3D BIM for Substations—Driving Efficiency from Design Through Operation and Maintenance

In this webinar, PESTECH will describe their transition to intelligent substation design and its ...

High Availability Networks. Application of IEC6439-3 Protocols for IEC61850 Process Bus implementation

Networks can now be built for the first time with genuinely uninterrupted data communication betw...

Understanding Moisture Dynamics in Power Transformers

While the need to measure moisture in power transformers has been well documented and is universa...

EL&P BUYER'S GUIDE PRODUCTS

MITEM Corp

Provides CRM solutions for regulated U.S. public utilities. The product, MitemView integrates differently designed systems to share critical data a...

Resources on Demand

Manages resource requests, tracks personnel movements, and supports lodging/logistics during a power restoration event.

Smart Grids

Quanta is contributing to its customers' smart grid initiatives by installing technology on power networks to provide energy management solutions f...

Horizontal Directional Drilling

With 28 small, mid-sized and large drilling rigs, Quanta Pipeline Services is one of the largest horizontal directional contractors in the world fo...

FEATURED ENERGY JOBS

View more Job Listings >>

POWERGRID International

March 2014
Volume 19, Issue 3
1403PG-cover

ELECTRIC LIGHT & POWER

January 2014
cover